Liberty Tree Tavern Pilgrim's Feast

*This dining experience took place in January 2016. 

Liberty Tree Tavern

Photo Taken by Gluten Free & Dairy Free at WDW

Hear ye, hear ye! Liberty Tree Tavern, located in Liberty Square in the Magic Kingdom, finally re-opened a few months ago after a lengthy refurbishment to accommodate for the newly opened (and shared kitchen space for) Skipper Canteen in Adventureland. Having missed out on Liberty Tree Tavern during the holiday season (a family tradition), I finally got a chance to get in my Disney turkey dinner cravings.

Liberty Tree Tavern offers an a la carte lunch and family style all-you-care-to-eat dinner. Typically, my family dines here during dinner, which offers a full Pilgrim’s Feast with all the trimmings; however, on this occasion, we chose to grab lunch. Though no allergy friendly menu is given for dinner, guests will receive an allergy friendly menu when they dine a la carte for lunch. In looking at the menu, I was glad to see some options, including the New England Pot Roast with mashed potatoes which can be served gluten and dairy free.

Our server did ask several times if I preferred to speak to a chef or order directly from the allergy friendly menu. Having dined at Liberty Tree Tavern numerous times and ordering the Pilgrim’s Feast, I felt comfortable ordering without speaking with a chef.

Typically, I do still speak to a chef but since the dishes were completely gluten free and dairy free without modifications (and the server wrote my order on the yellow food allergy notification pad), I felt OK ordering straight from the menu. Of course, if you ever dine at a Disney location and don’t feel comfortable with the options or allergy friendly menu, you can always talk to a Disney chef. Just ask your server!

Liberty Tree Tavern Salad

Photo Taken by Gluten Free & Dairy Free at WDW

First on my order was the traditional house salad served with a strawberry vinaigrette. It’s a classic Liberty Tree Tavern dish, and a must order for me. I did ask for an extra side of vinaigrette as in previous years (and on this visit), the salad was woefully under-dressed.

Liberty Tree Tavern Ener-G Rolls

Photo Taken by Gluten Free & Dairy Free at WDW

I also inquired about gluten free and dairy free rolls and Earth Balance Vegan Margarine. Unfortunately, I was given Ener-G rolls, which I don’t really enjoy. Last year when I dined here, I was given GNI brand rolls which I love, but Ener-G gets very dry and has a Styrofoam texture that is very unappealing. Though I appreciated the offering, I didn’t eat much of them. Sadly, not even dipping it in their gluten free and dairy free gravy could save these rolls.

Liberty Tree Tavern Pilgrim's Feast

Photo Taken by Gluten Free & Dairy Free at WDW

For my entree, I chose the Pilgrim’s Feast which is a lighter version of the dinner offering. It only comes with turkey instead of three meats, but this was fine with me. Accompanying the turkey were dairy free mashed potatoes, green beans, and gluten free and dairy free stuffing and gravy.

The turkey was super moist and delicious and the mashed potatoes were outstanding. Is it wrong that I get that excited over a dairy free mashed potato? It’s a rarity in restaurants, but seriously so easy to make. To add to this is Liberty Tree’s gluten free gravy, which I adore. My whole family also prefers it to the regular gluten-filled version of gravy that is served in the restaurant. It’s probably because we grew up eating holiday gravy based in cornstarch instead of flour, and this version tastes very similar to what we have always served at home.

The green beans were nothing spectacular. Just a plain steamed veg.

The gluten free and dairy free stuffing was just OK on this visit. The taste was great but the texture was off. I’m not sure if they are using a different type of bread or if they just added too much liquid to the mixture. The texture was very mushy and almost a bit gritty. When I went last November, I had this and absolutely loved it. It was the perfect texture and taste. This time, it just wasn’t as good as it was the year before. That being said, I’d definitely give it a try again.

Overall, Liberty Tree Tavern consistently serves up holiday inspired fare, making it the perfect holiday season restaurant. It’s not one I’d dine at all the time, but during Thanksgiving and Christmas it’s an absolute must-do for me. There’s really no other restaurant around that can serve up gluten free and dairy free stuffing, gravy, and mashed potatoes!

Have you been to Liberty Tree Tavern? What did you think of their allergy friendly offerings?

Share: